These apple hand pies live in the space I strive to hit when it comes to baking – classic, rustic, with a bit of a wink or surprise. I make them with a strong, homemade apple butter filling. The smooth kind. Like when you were a kid. But I add a bit of miso to it for some depth. The crust is showered generously with sugar and sesame then kissed with a bit of red chile flakes. Bake it to the point where it crisps and caramelizes, you have the sugar crust dreams are made of.
Apple Cinnamon Hand Pies: The Ingredients
- Pie Dough: Your hand pies are only as good as your pastry. I use this pie crust. It is flaky, structured, and easy to work with. It bakes into deep, golden buttery deliciousness.
- Apple Butter: Thick, concentrated, homemade apple butter is the filling for these hand pies. You can make it when apples are in season, and the apple butter will keep, refrigerated, for a couple weeks. It will keep frozen for up to six months. I try to fill each pie as full as possible and still get them sealed.
- Sesame-Sugar-Chile Crust: I like some texture to play off the smooth filling here. After an egg wash, each hand pie is sprinkled with large granulated sugar that has been tossed with sesame seeds and red chile flakes (I use these smoked red chile flakes). Some of the sugar melts and caramelizes, the sesame gets toasted, and you get little pops of heat from the chile flakes. So good.
How To Make Apple Cinnamon Hand Pies
Here’s the step-by-step of how to make these hand pies. You need pie dough, apple butter filling, egg wash, and sesame-sugar sprinkle. They’re super simple to pull together (really!). You start by rolling out your pie dough. Then make large circles using a cookie cutter (or bowl, like I did).
Brush a bit of egg around the perimeter of each pastry, then add a couple tablespoons of filling. (pictured below)
Carefully fold in half, pressing along the edge with your finger to create a seal. Use a fork to reinforce that seal all along the edge of each pie. (pictured below)
Arrange on a parchment lined baking sheet. Brush with more egg, and sprinkle generously with a sesame-sugar mixture. (pictured below)
Bake until deeply golden. 
Make Ahead:
The two main components here are the pie crust and the filling. Both can be prepped ahead of time. Both can be frozen for weeks/months.
- Pie Dough: If you keep pie dough in the freezer, transfer it to your refrigerator a day before you want to roll out and fill your hand pies.
- Filling: You can make the apple butter filling a week or two in advance of filling your hand pies.
- Freezer Hand Pies: Once you’ve assembled your hand pies, they freeze wonderfully. Freeze in a single layer on a parchment-lined baking sheet or plate. Transfer to a container for up to a couple months. When you’re ready to bake the hand pies, brush them with eggs, sprinkle with sesame seeds, and cut a couple slashes in the top of each pie before placing in the oven.
More Hand Pie Recipes
- Mushroom Hand Pies
- Peach Hand Pies
More Pie Recipes
- Shaker Lemon Pie
- Pumpkin Pie
- Deep Dish Quiche
- Shaker Apple Pie
- Vegan Samosa Shepherd’s Pie
- Vegetable Pot Pie
- Berry Pie
- Coconut Cream Pie
Continue reading Apple Cinnamon Hand Pies on 101 Cookbooks
